[TexasKat08]

Originally Posted by dawn27

And "No" ....I am not trying to convince you or anyone else of anything. I was not aware that that had been established, I thought that this was an "open" discussion and that those are your views and opinions. Actually, this is the recommendation of the YTCA, not my opinion, but yes I do agree that it is what is right. Not necessarily mine. Clearly.


Maybe I did not answer the question right? Although, not fact based by an expert.. it is my opinion! I would hope that before somebody decides to become a breeder, they might also become an expert in the complexities of doing so.

I do not think that just because a pup goes to its new home before 12 weeks of age makes that pup any less capable of thriving or becoming a happy, healthy well socialized member of the family. I didn't say that and don't disagree. I know that this IS possible; but again, I agree with the recommendation of the YTCA. I think that there is no better place for a puppy to get the socialization skills, human contact and the training that it so desperately needs than in a loving environment in their own home. On this I would have to disagree. At whatever age that be.  Whether it be at the age of 12 weeks or as early as 8 weeks of age ?

Agree to disagree. However, I think you should disclose that you are a breeder that homes puppies at 8 weeks and not just a random person voicing your opinion. IMO, that is an important consideration for the random member seeking advice to determine whether your opinions are based on what is best for the puppy or what is best for the breeder.