Trixie is in our bed every night....we started off in the crate and then when she was housebroken I would bring her into our bed when she woke up at 5 am so I could sleep later otherwise she would whine till I got up. of course, 5 am became 4 am then 3 am and so on....she wouldn't even be in her crate for 5 minutes and she wanted out. Score: Trixie 1 Me 0 - unless you count having a very warm, loving bedmate winnin- then I definitely won.