I bought my puppies a couple at the pet store and they smelled bad before they even put them in their mouths but 2 of my babies really liked them. There is a site by one of the YTers on here called
www.westbrookdogs.com I think. Anyway the sticks are a great price, the shipping is fast and the smell is not bad at all.
That is where I get mine now.
Good Luck in your search.