You noticed I didn't give treats just lots of praise I'll tell you why
My neighbor got a boston terrier pup right before I got Roxy and they gave her a treat everytime she pottied outside..well guess what! These little buggers are so smart that the dog started peeing right at her feet in the house to get a treat!!! They did some retraining and she is now on the right track! She couldn't understand why the dog would squat right in front of her in the house!! The dog was no dummy, she wanted a treat!!