Belle does the same thing with taking them all out of the basket. She may want the first or second one out but they have to all come out first. She also has specific toys for different times. I made her a toy out of the empty plastic grape juice can when I put a tennis ball in there and she loves this toy. She lays it down and runs at it and picks it up and throws it. I never knew a dog could throw something so high. This is what she has to get out while I am fixing her food. I always have to check the recycle pail and the garbage before I take it out as the toy has landed in there a few times. She is really hard on her toys, especially anything stuffed. It only takes her a few minutes to have stuffing all over the floor. I did finally find a toy that she can't destroy and she actually loves it. It's a Hartz durasoft squeeky toy, she has one that is a small ball and one that is what I can't even describe. It's really strange looking as it has like six heads (my husband makes fun of it and says they look like green penis)
It's a great toy and it has outlasted the Morkie destroyer!