WOW he got the squeaker out already? I bought Holly one today, the small size, and she's been going CRAZY. I can't believe I found an actual toy that she will play with by herself haha. She doesn't let our other dogs even come close!
Have you tried the teething toys made out of the strong crocheted material? They have squeakers, but are really hard to get into to take it out, just because it's thoroughly knitted.. Don't know how to explain, but they're pretty hard to rip open, especially for their little teeth. My dad's dachshund and my Holly were attacking one and couldn't even come close!
Crochet Football Dog Toy Crochet Monkey Dog Toy