Your title...definitely a twist on the Napoleon Dynamite line??? (aka "Tina") Too funny...I LOVE that flippin' movie! Regarding your post, Willie is a cutie, but I can't tell from the avatar pic if he's overweight. 11lbs is certainly not excessive if he has the right frame. I would ask for a copy of his records from the vet so you can see for yourself what his weight was each time. If no significant weight gain is noted, I'd grill the vet on exactly what he means by "fat" and ask him to show you on Willie.