Again, my daughter has seen awesome results from the Neutrogena ID program....
Personalized Acne Treatment Solutions ? Neutrogena Skin iD
It also has benzoyl peroxide in it so can stain your pillowcase but I think it's way better than Proactive. There's an introductory offer plus you can google for a $10 off coupon. If it doesn't give you the results you want, it can be returned. I know some people aren't viligent about returning stuff if they don't like it but we were determined to do just that if it didn't work. She is SO much happier with her complexion now.
Whatever you decide.... good luck!