I am glad to hear the bells are working for each of you. I bought the Poochie Bells months ago and began using them immediately. We have consistently rang the bells and said "potty outside" to the point that Duke will sit, look at the bells and wait for us to ring them , he does not want anything to do with them. I have tried peanut butter, treat rewards, lifting him up to hit the bells with his paw and attaching one of his small toys on the end of the ribbon....no reaction whatsoever except scared if I lift him up to the bells. Duke is 9 months old now and potty accidents are minimal, but then again I have learned to ask him to go outside before the accident happens. I wonder if I am rushing him outside to soon and not giving him a chance to ring the bells.
~Jessica and My Lil Duke