I gave them two each yesterday evening and Bogie gobbled his down. Jada was funny with hers she took it out of my hand then spit it out, tried to hide it under a pillow on the couch. I got it out from under the pillow and she grabbed it away from me. She let it sit in her mouth and got the middle out then spit out the peel. Then she got it and ate it. The second one I gave her she gobbled it down.