Because the new owner insisted on taking the puppy even though it was only eight weeks old, Toni said that she could not give a written health guarantee. All of the facts were presented in court, from the Plaintiff and the Defendant, and after reviewing all the evidence, the Judge ruled in favor of Toni. Now, let's just let the case rest and get on with sharing other Yorkie news ~ it's been on the radar screen way too long and Toni has been hurt enough. The Judge was an unbiased outsider, and the Court felt that the documentation that Toni provided was more than adequate to clear her name and reputation.