I am SO glad I came across this thread! I just received some samples of Natural Balance that I requested a couple of weeks ago. I have the beef and rice roll, the duck and potato treat roll and some dry duck and potato kibble. Neo is wishy-washy on the d/p roll and won't touch the dry, but almost eats my fingers when I offered the b/r roll! He has got to be THE pickiest eater in Alabama(besides my DH)! My main concern was if this was really a good food for him and wanted Yorkie Talk opinions.