Congrats on your new baby girl and WELCOME to YT!! As you can tell, we're all extremly biased as we love this site. So many people with good information and we have a forum for basically anything you'd want to know. Get to know the search button, it will be your best friend.
As for toys I'd recommend, Kaji is my first dog, and he's still coming out of his shell. So far the only acceptable toys in the house are:
KONG X-Small Plush Dog Toys - Toys - Dog - PetSmart Kong Squeaker Balls - Small : Target
Anything else gets left in his little tent and it not used at all.
