Well we are switched over to the origen red, and everyone is adjusting fairly well. No one quit eating on me like they did with the fish, Dakota hasnt had any skin issues with it. So we in it for the long haul and hopefully will see a difference in a few months with some minor scratching issues. Suki, my love Im afraid hers is enviornmental alergies though, I hope Im wrong and this helps her too. If nothing else, they are eating a much better food, especially poor Dakota who was stuck with Hills zd ultra only.