My 4 month old reacts the same way. I also live in Manhattan and Chi Chi whines for about 20 minutes before I leave and probably longer after I leave. I don't crate her, I gated her and it doesn't make a difference - she still whines. I think it's more of a separation anxiety thing then the crate.
To counteract the whining, I have resorted to leaving her in my bedroom with the door closed, that way, she can't see me leave and I don't feel as guilty. And she doesn't whine as long. Plus she gets to roam around my room, so she has more space. I think she is also comforted by my scent as it is all around my bedroom and she lays on my laundry bag while I'm away - and I think it makes her feel better.
I let her roam around the apt once and I was a nervous wreck! They can find a way to get into something. I would suggest gating off a section, the pen or keeping your pet confined to one area of the house. Best of luck! |