When I went to pick out Maddie it was between her and her sister. They were pretty much identical from their coloring to their weight, everything about their appearance was the same. I was holding the two girls in my lap and looking them over. One of the puppies was sitting in my lap shaking and the other sat there with her tail wagging and then climbed right up to my face and attacked it with puppy kisses, she definitely chose me, I didn't have any say in it
