Lots of the stuff toys I bring home are good for garbage after 5min.
I found that
hide-a-squirrel is a pretty good stuff toy. They have been playing with it VERY ruffly for a over 6 months now and I still have 2 out of the 3 little squirrels left.
Also, my dog also love their
skunk stuff toy from Ty . Almost a year old and still look good coming out of the washing machine.