I took our baby to the vet, and they said it looked like she had an injury on the surface of her eye, but thought it had actually been there longer, but was hidden under her eye lid. He thinks the milky/cloudy whiteness is due to the process of healing, along with the general redness around the eye. He prescribed her eye drops, 4 times a day to help with discomfort. He said the milky coloration may not go away, but it won't affect her vision at all. The very next morning after taking her to the vet, her eye looked so much better! I'm so happy.
Thank you to all who posted. Good luck with your babies, and may they live a long, healthy, and loving life.
!!