Belle was trained on pads and newspapers when we got her. Living in Minnesota (we got her in January) there was no way she could go out and alot of dogs in the neighborhood so I wouldn't let her in the grass. She has stuck with the pads (seperate ones for pee and pooping) They work so good. My only problem is lately when she pees near the edge of the pad holder, it runs out onto the floor (tile)? Anyone else had this happen? If I put another pad under the holder, she thinks she can stand on the edge of that and pee and it counts as good

We do take her camping with us in the RV and I use her pads especially for night or bad weather. The first time I saw her pee outside I got so excited, my baby was a big girl now!