Quote:
Originally Posted by Nancy1999  I have a problem with using the word "mutilate " to describe tail docking, there are lots of different opinions on this, and I tend to believe those who say if done correctly at the right age causes very little discomfort. Are they lying about this, or are others exaggerating? I really don't know the truth. However, the problem with exaggerating things is that you tend to get people to ignore you on other things. Should tail docking be compared to debarking by ramming a rod down a dogs throat, or a non-medical person doing a cesarean? Tail docking just doesn’t seem to be as barbaric a procedure as some suggest, and laws like this are more likely to get good breeders to just feel like they are being attacked on all fronts, making it even more difficult to get the good laws passed that will indeed protect our dogs. |
Well said Nancy. As for the law in NY regarding docking, it was not defeated, it was referred to the agriculture committee. The AKC website has a link to follow all pending legislation in each state and it's current status. The way the law has been written in NY, anyone who exhibits a dog in NY with docked tails WOULD be subjected to a fine of $500 (each animal). The law is unclear on how one would or if they even could prove the docking occurred prior to the enactment of the law. Effectively, NO ONE with ANY dog breed having been docked would be able to show in NY. Westminster, as well as ALL other shows would have to be cancelled or moved out of state. Unfortunately, there are many laws pending in many states which are poorly written and have repercussions that are probably unintended, but many are just bad for individuals rights - making breeding of any purebred dogs, with or without docking, cropping, etc., impossible or nearly impossible. As responsible pet owners, we should stay informed and contact our legislators and let them know we vote!
Here is a website from the dogwriters assoc.
NY Assembly anti-tail-docking bill: NY A07218 - Dog Writers Association of America Forums
Here is the link to AKC's legislative alerts: (sorted by state)
American Kennel Club - Government Relations - Legislation