Well, I vote for Instinct!
Jackson has been eating the NV Instinct Turkey & Duck flavor for 3 weeks now and is lovin' it. Moreso than any other food he's ever eaten before. He eats the dry all by itself, which he's never done before in his life, hardly.
I was worried about the high protein as well and that's why I settled w/ Instinct because it's 35% protein. It's still considered high to some, but it's not quite as high as the Orijen's or Evo's, etc. He's an active dog so I feel comfortable feeding it and it's the only food he loves so we're sticking with it. I think there's always going to be controversy w/ dog foods and you just have to go w/ what you feel is right and healthiest for your dog.