[rebeccag]

I didn't hear anyone agree with her. She posted for advice. I gave her some tips on how to get the pup to like the crate. I think most of us know the crate should be a happy place and if it isn't you can change that. Naturally, you don't leave him in the crate all day. I did hear people say that using the crate is effective is used properly but I don't think anyone said..."you're doing everything right, continue doing what your doing". There are useful posts on this thread with good advice.