[ldenise]

i am far from being an expert here but i know what you are going thru. i also had a rough time with ahia and was unsure if i did the right thing when we first got her. it seemed like it was losing the battle. consistancy was the key. i had to keep an eye on her every moment. what i did was to offer a treat every time she pottied out side. that was the only time she got a treat for a while. she got the idea eventually. even faking a peeing to get a treat. when i caught her peeing on the floor i would startle her and say out and take her immidately out. she will even scratch or bark at me in the middle of the night to wake me up when she has to go out. i got good advice on YT. chose one method and stick with it. time will make it all easier. hang in there.