There is always hope.. no sense in getting frustrated... glad it worked for you.. they do come along.. gracie took one year to not pp in the hallway at night.. my pepsie when he was young.. pooped in the house for well over a year.. but he would poop then bark to go to pp out side.. go figure.. but he did get it.. as I do not punish... but reward when good.. and I was also working then too... make it harder to train outside...
anne |