What a tough decision. When I picked my pup we picked by a description then confirmed with a picture. We were suppose to get the smaller girl, then I visited twice and we changed our minds to the biggest girl (there was just something about her
) and now we are coming home with the biggest girl and the small boy! So I am probably no help. I think the second pup is a doll but their is just something about #1. I would definately ask for more pictures of them playing, body shots and if possible a video of them running around.