The only thing I don't like about Grandma Lucy's Pumpkin Treats is that they contain wheat flour which can cause allergies. I always buy wheat free products for Lady.
Thrive makes a pumpkin spice treat that I get for her. They are made with oat flour, not wheat flour. They smell good enough to eat!
SuperTreats Pro-Immune Pumpkin Spice - Healthy Dog Treats from Thrive Foods