I'm starting to warm up to the Virtual Treasure Chest idea.
One thing that would be nice is that it would be much easier to have multiple chests going for toys, carriers, M/F - S/M/L clothing.
Here is another question: what happens if you list something, it sits there for a while, and then three months later, someone asks for it? And you haven't logged in that week? Do we have rules that things must be shipped by a certain time, or do we rely on people's good nature (and attentiveness to YT) to ship it out at some point?
With a real box, you know when you are next in line, and it's clear when you need to send it along.
I'm still envisioning that people take turns so that there are no arguments about who gets a hot item.