I just got the bully sticks in the mail... so I guess they didn't respond to my message. They don't seem to smell REALLY REALLY Bad. But he hasn't chewed on them yet. I don't know if the smell comes out gradually, LOL. I mean, they definitely have a little more of a barn smell then the bully sticks in petsmart and such. I guess I will just keep them. They were only $9.99 and I'll give some to my moms dog, she will eat those things pretty quick lol |