I see Lil differently, and think when Simon told her she was not a true artist; it cut her to the quick, her face just dropped. Taking an example from painting, there are some people who can copy the works of masters, but can't create anything unique on their own. To be a true artist in singing you not only need great vocals, you need to create something that sets you apart from all others who sing the same song, and give it your own stamp. Few singers actually write their own music, and must rely on the creative talents of others to set them apart. Unfortunately, I think Lil has taken Simon's comment on not being an artist, and tried to put her stamp on a song, but instead just hacks up the song. I think she has tried to reach out and find what she thought others wanted and liked instead of what really really rocks her soul. So the contestants always have to play a guessing game on what they think will be a popular choice, and get them lots of votes, and what will really shows their true individuality. |