I know I'm a little late to add my two cents...but
I'm in my 40's and Adam has completely won me over.

Like Mike, dh and I find ourselves looking forward to what he does each week. I can't say that I'd ever go to one of his concerts but I will be buying his version of "Mad World"...what a beautiful performance.
Danny Gokey was my favorite in the beginning, but honestly, he's getting boring. I'm still routing for him, but I hope he surprises us soon.
I love Allison. I can't pick on her personality, mg she's 16. When I think about the choices I made at 16

I certainly can't expect a lot from her. But her voice is amazing. I think she always sounds like a real pro.
Kris and Matt are also very talented.
I liked Scott, but I agree that it was his time to go. There's just a lot of great talent this year.
Lil? I forget about her from week to week...anyone else find that happening?