Thats very sad but I have to say that my dog was pretty skinny herself. She ate alot even when she was 3.5 and had gained a lb and was up to 4.8 lbs she felt the same, some yorkies are built differently and may be "boney" if you so call it. Also I'm not trying to defend but as someone who didn't know any better even 8 months ago I have to say that some people don't find these kinds of websites and just don't know better that there is better quality food out there. I had puppy chow before for my dog and I didn't know it was bad. I mean I knew it wasnt the best food but then again I thought Science diet was one of the best foods you could get. So you never really know what people are thinking, just because you can afford an expensive dog doesn't mean you know how to take care of them great. I know some breeders who claim Royal Canin is a great food for yorkies, everyone has a different opinion so because they feed cheap food doesn't mean we have to bash them, they simply may not know any better