Furthermore, if this dog is now marking and is not fixed what do you think he will be like after she allows him to breed? It is known that after a male is allowed to breed the marking will increase and their personality changes as well. I can only imagine how he will then be peeing all over her apartment. Look into neutering him, getting him a crate and stop the punishing/nose rubbing.
__________________ “Never argue with a fool, onlookers may not be able to tell the difference.”  Mark Twain |