I was using Chicken Soup and it worked well, but with five I looked to see if I could buy a similar product in bulk and found Kirkland brand at Cosco. I did research through Google and it had a good rating. I don't see it on the website that was just linked on this thread but it may be something some of you guys with multiple dogs want to look into. If anyone finds something different about it then what I thought I'd appreciate the input. Anyway back to the original poster Chicken Soup is a nice product and the size is perfect for your pup. They are flat too not round so they won't choke. I had used Nutro and my little one choked on it (They are small and round). Elaine |