I usually have a superbowl party each year, and have since I was like 12! We're skipping out this year, waiting for the stork to arrive
I always used to make Jello Jigglers in the colors of the team we were rooting for-you can add vodka too to make Jello Jigglers shots for the adults.
Brownies-but cut out the shape of a football/laces in printer paper and put on top, then dust with powdered sugar and take off the paper, and voila you have stencils. You can also frost them to look like a football field with yardlines.
Chex Mix
White Chicken Chili-with tortilla chips, jack cheese, chives and jalapenos
Or how about an easy dip-take a brick of cream cheese, pour over a jar of jalapeno jelly, and serve with crackers...looks like so much more but it's so easy!