Don't give up! Snoopy is 10 months old, too, and is just now getting to where he doesn't potty on the floor (not usually anyway). They are rascals, though, that's for sure! That's what I love about Snoopy. He's not one to cuddle too much, either, but I wait for him to get tired, and I swoop in! We did take him to puppy class--it was great for socialization, and also to see how he compared to other puppies. We didn't think he was picking it up, but he was better than a lot of the other pups. If you really love her, hang in there! 
