Innova is definitely superior to beneful. As the previous poster mentioned, some are concerned with the high protein content and others are concerned with the fat content. It all depends on your individual dog as to whether or not your baby will do well on it.
If the choice is b/w innova and beneful, I would pick innova any day of the week
If you want to stick with Chicken Soup, have you checked on Chicken Soup's website to see if anyone else close to you sells it?
Here's a link for you to check that:
http://www.chickensoupforthepetlover...ealer_locator/