Hi...I have been gone for awhile and just read this post. Tish will do anything for her greenie. THEY DO NOT CALM THEM

at all. When I give her one she will spend one day trying to hide it in a corner somewhere. Sometimes she will carry it around for days. Then she will finally eat it starting at the brush side. I will fine ends lying around everwhere. So I cut them up in tiny pieces and use it for treats when she does her tricks. She will be 1yr. on april 3.