Kim,
I am sorry if you feel that you were attacked or otherwise felt you were not being treated with respect. It's hard sometimes to give advise, when you don't know the whole story. I'm sorry if I said things that you didn't agree with and felt were mean, I didn't intend them to be! I was just going off what I saw in your original post.
From what you've said it sounds like you've tried a lot! Since it seems like you've gone through all of my suggestions I'm out of ideas, sorry! Honestly, for all we try to give our opinions and our advise, he's your dog and you know what's best for him! Take things with a grain of salt and decide for yourself what you think is best! I guess it's just going to take some persistence on your part, and some good cleaner!
Eventually he'll get it! (And I know all about shredding the puppy pads, little Zoe just doesn't get it, I gave up on those while she's in her X-pen a LONG time ago...)
Sorry for all of the harsh comments, know that I had no intentions of coming off as rude or cruel! Again, best of luck with your little difficult monster!
