LOL, I totally understand about the Bully Sticks

, they're not for everyone. The ones I have don't really smell, but some vendors' have really smelly ones. I get mine on eBay.
I don't think there is anything wrong w/ rotating, per se. Personally, I just think raw is superior - and the benefits of raw are so wonderful, that I'd rather just feed raw - period - and not feed the NV kibble or canned. But, if for some reason I had to feed kibble or canned - NV would be the brand I'd use. NV's raw contains non-synthetic vitamins and minerals, all natural enzymes - meat in its natural state. Of course, with the kibble and canned - the meat has been cooked, so they have to add back in the enzymes, and vits/minerals, etcetera. So, I just would rather feed raw all the time

. And, my guys teeth are just gorgeous since going totally raw too. But, if the rotations suits you best, then go for it!