Thanks everyone! I can't believe all the responses this got! And all of the great ideas!!! THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH!
I'm totally going to keep all of it in mind for future reference!
Well, I was on vacation while most of this happened
Before I left I had tried
every pet store in town and our Toys R Us, no success. The only stuffed animals I found that didn't have squeakers had little beads and I wasn't going to get any of those!
Well, while I was away I went to an IKEA store. (For the first time, it was very cool, my whole family thought it was hilarious but we all loved going! There were tons of great things there and a lot of things I'd wanted to get but simply couldn't since I couldn't carry or check them in my luggage and couldn't afford the crazy shipping. My boyfriend and I are already trying to plan a trip to a store close to us--aka in our own state--to get those few items.
)
Anyway, they had kids things, including stuffed animals! So I went a little crazy, just a little, since they were perfect and cheap! So we got her the
amazingly soft rabbit, the white and gray mice, and the adorable hippo that'll be close to her size for a large cuddle animal.