Thank you all. I will talk to scootiebootie. I have noticed some very positive posts from her on training ... that must be why!

Thank you again nancy for the advice.
Yeah he's always been a fearful pup, he's just getting worse. Its like he has anxiety to everything basically and Im afraid of his quality of life. I hate to see him so fearful but you know I do baby him. He just shakes sooo hard and it breaks my heart.