I used to work at that store for a holiday season and got to smell/try or buy like all of their scents. Some are amazing, some are disgusting!
I LOVE a scent they discontinued years ago, when it was around I stocked up but Im all out of it pretty much. All I have left is a bottle of the spray.

It was called Rich Citrus Cream. It was a vanilla lime scent... sooo yummy! I still love Sweet Pea and sun riped raspberry. Im surprised they are doing away with cucumber melon, thats like their signature scent. hhhmmm