[MeganS]

Diane, I think you've got a point. Something about his personality just really bugs me, I guess. He seems so unimpressed by everything when there are people who are DYING to have the opportunities he has. Maybe I'm just crazy or upset or something, but I just find him to be almost totally ungrateful for what the public has GIVEN him - or if he is grateful he really stinks at showing it.

and plus, I just don't think he's that great of a singer. Maybe if he was more of a performer. He doesn't perform, he just sits there and sings. I mean, he's a good singer. If he was just some random guy singing somewhere, then I'd think he has an amazing voice. But he's on American Idol - alongside some of the best singers in the country - and I just don't think he's good enough.

And last night just really...did him in for me. He totally destroyed that song, IMO. I'm all for people putting their own spins on things - but that was just a little crazy. I know that he didn't realize how big of a song he was doing. But if he was preparing to sing that song, then IMO, he should have been actually studying the SONG and what it IS, not just the music.