My thoughts!!
Syesha~~Lookout Jennifer Hudson! Syesha showed performing on Broadway or in the movies with her powerful voice is RIGHT where she belongs too! Not my vote for Idol, but I was so happy for her tonight.
Jason~~ouch! Not your genre! He has made it much further than I thought. Hes funny and cutie, quirky, but not idol to me.....
Brooke~~This was bound to happen. I have always felt she is sweet but NOT a performer. She cant dance, perform AND I think she really hurt her career tonight by starting over this time. The 1st time she did it I thought it was smart, but tonight, IMO was about performing too and on Broadway, etc....you dont ask to start over. BIG MISTAKE. And I was so bugged that Simon and Randy were so easy on her for that. KUDOS to doofy Paula for FINALLY speaking a real opinion!! Brooke is sweet, but I thought her last 3 weeks were too weak to move forward
David A. awww...sorry, I lost it only because I liked the original version better and I thought he swayed too far away from that. Cant hate the sweet guy for tryin to mix it up though! One other thing though, like it was pointed out, I think David lacks a little in delivering a "performance" (dancing, keeping eyes open!, etc.) He has a beautiful voice that will take him far but Im picking he will go to #3!!
Carly~~Thought she did great. The judges have been so tough on her because they know her potential and dont think shes delivered that top notch performance yet, but I think they are still not giving her enough credit for her all around skills. She is still barely hanging onto my vote for #2!
David C!! So impressive. Its really great to see a rocker still show a performing arts side. Talk about a true musician!! Gee, does it suprise you then that he has always had my vote for IDOL?!?!
So there's my Tana's Top six round up!!
Feel free to send me your "What are you thinking pm's!!!"
