Sorry guys, I forgot about this thread when I made the other one!
My thoughts..
Syesha - I'm looking forward to seeing her on Broadway. That seems to be her strong point, and she seems to love it. I'm sure that she'll show up there in the near future.
David A - Nicely done. NOT my favorite tonight. It took me a minute to get over the shock of him changing up that song. But overall, I thought he did well.
Brooke - ouch. I feel bad for her. I really think she did the right thing by stopping to start over - she aknowledged that she messed up, and probably did better than she would have if she just tried to cover it up.
Jason - ow. I'm sorry to his fans, but I've never really been fond of him and this just reinforced it. IMO, he slaughtered that song. It was slightly painful and I felt bad for him.
Carly - VERY VERY nicely done. She owned that song.
David Cook - Just beyond wow. There are no adjectives left to describe that performance. I was in awe...almost crying - no joke. I voted for him like 17 times.