[blitz]

Originally Posted by BakersDozen

Yes, of course I realize this. The breeder who doesn't have it done was talking about dogs with no history in their lines. (at least that is what I gathered, I might have misunderstood) That is what I was comparing to no 'family history.'

How do they know for sure? Puppies that die are not all autopsied. How about puppies that are resorbed or stillborn? I would venture a guess that any breeder who will have a necropsy performed on these puppies, will also go for the BAT.

I'm just pointing out that the mere fact that it is prevelant doesn't necessarily necessitate the testing of every dog.

Well, then how do YOU suggest that MVD be uncovered if it asymptomatic?

In the US, diabetes is much more prevelant in Mexican Americans, blacks, and American Indians. But it is not reasonable or necessary for every single person in those groups to automatically do a fasting test. They are tested when they show some sign or symptom, or when a routine test indicates otherwise.

Obviously, that analogy does not apply to the topic. If diabetes were rampent AND asymptomatic, I bet there would be routine testing.

I agree that there is no compelling reason NOT to BAT every Yorkie. But I also feel there is no compelling reason TO BAT every Yorkie, in the absence of any indication there might be a problem.....

Well, then how do you propose to work towards eradicting or at least controlling this disease?

Assuming there is great familiarity with the bloodline(s), and the other precautions already mentioned in this thread. (Please note I am not referring to breeding two dogs you know nothing about, without testing.) Since BAT won't tell you if you have two dogs with recessive genes, you could still produce offspring with liver shunt anyway.

But BAT could clear your dog inasmuch as you can clear a dog and that is all one can do. We can't sit on our hands and wait and wait for the genetic marker that is going to be found any day now and in the meantime continue to breed with crossed fingers.

Again, just my opinion.

To which you are entitled but you dont' sound proactive.