im Not sure cause he truely only does when he is playing and thanks for the can advice just telling him No firmly doesnt seem to work and lol belive me when i say this lol I have a loud voice gotten in trouble for it alot in my life LOL (it makes me laugh to say this cause besides gettin in trouble for it i truely never noticed untill my older kid said gee Mom when you come to my class can you not talk cause your too loud LOL ) i was so embarased ... but hey out of the mouth of babes i think they speak more truth then any one out here

but that is a nother story do have any other ideas to help besides the can ive never done the water bottle thing i have 2 kids who are water babies so that i cant have lying around the house it be a water fight 24 7 here lol ty again Julie and Memphis