ty u all i wi try the things that u have tried and see if they work for me... he is getting better ... since i posted i have made him a good size box that i keep him in wen i am at work ... he has learned to go on the papers wen he is in the box ... but wen i take him out and move the box out of the way and put the papers in the same spot he still goes every were else but at least we can watch him wen we are home and put him on the papers and tell him thats were to potty ty again