I've given mine the other flavors of Nylabone Edibles and they love them. The only problem I've had (and I had it with Greenies too) is that they'd eat it down to a big chunk and then want to just eat the whole chunk so I had to watch them very carefully to throw it away before they started doing that. I don't give them anything edible anymore because Tuffy has a very sensitive stomach but I recommend them anyways because they are great for them to chew on.