Netgear is definitely better. We had some degraded service and switched and we are good to go. We are running three pcs off of it and also two xbox 360's simultaneously and no problems. I will only see a lower speed if I am persay sending big files while they are playing.
We got the Netgear becuase a friend of ours and fellow gamer with hubby is an IT guy and he put us on to it.
If you want I can send you the model we have. We got it at
www.newegg.com for cheaper than the other spots.